By Cassie Bingham A comprehensive blog of my experience preparing for and conducting a 3 month field research project in Ghana, Africa. Here I will document my insights, notes, literary sources and more. The blog title is one of my favorite Passion Pit lyrics, and a good piece of advice for all inhabitants of the world! Please see my Project Proposal page for an overview of my project and proposed ethnographic field work.
Wednesday, February 29, 2012
Confessions of an Addict
Tuesday, February 28, 2012
Extra Credit Post
An English major who presented at the Inquiry Conference talked about her project carried out in London, based on classic literature about Queen Elizabeth. She started off her presentation by stating that at first she had wanted to do her project here at BYU, gathering research in the library. Her professors had encouraged her to actually go to London, an idea she was at first not too excited about. She did not understand how spending money to live in Europe would aid her project in worthwhile ways that would be any more beneficial than library research. However, she related that after she had arrived in London, and started visiting the locations written about in the classic literature she was studying, she quickly began to realize the benefits of being at the actual setting. She began to gather new insights and understandings about the literature she had never before thought of, because she had not known specific details about the settings until she experienced them visually and in person. For example, her views of the Queen Elizabeth character in her reading drastically changed once she physically visited the prison the queen had been held captive in. She felt a stronger connection and sympathy for the character, and had a deeper understanding of why she had been written to behave in some of the ways she did within the literature.
I felt that this presentation was extremely valid. Although library research is very useful, there is definitely something to be said about actually visiting a place or the people one is attempting to study. There are obvious reasons why relocating to the actual study region brings an added comprehension, sympathy, and new perspectives that could not otherwise be obtained through mere library research. I could try to study Wiamoase, Ghana through journal articles and books only, but I would not gain the same first-hand insights that I will be gaining by interviewing and living with actual residents of Wiamoase.
Humanitarian Relief
One of the inquiry conference presentations was by a Humanities major who studied a tourist site in Italy. Her presentation was titled something along the lines of “Inconclusive Study: Confessions of a Humanities Field Study Student” (I can’t remember the actually title). The presenter shared her learning experiences in Italy, but concluded by sharing the insights she had gained about a three-month undergraduate study. Basically, three months is a very short amount of time, and although she can make educated guesses and theoretical postulates, she knows she can not state definitive conclusions because they would be stereotypical and likely inaccurate. She related that the field study experience is wonderful and teaches students a lot, but that participants do not need to think they should return to the States with great revelations and conclusive breakthroughs. Even seasoned researchers who spend years doing ethnographic studies in one particular area cannot ever be completely sure about the conclusions and theories they acquire.
This presentation really helped me to feel relieved. As I work to gather sources for my project question and attempt to more fully comprehend its implications, I continue to feel overwhelmed, inadequate, and under qualified. I keep wondering to myself if there is any way my research could actually be valuable to academia, since it will be done in such a short amount of time, and by me, of so little experience. This girl’s presentation let me know that there are other field study students who feel the same way as me, and that this is okay. My undergraduate field study is a time to learn methods, procedures, and experience what it is like to develop a research question and carry out a study. It is okay that I cannot possibly come to complex and thorough conclusions that may not have any impact of influence on Ghanaians or anthropological academia. I am expanding my knowledge and experience, preparing for graduate school studies, and becoming more familiar with cross-cultural relations. I can do my best to contribute educated guesses about my project’s particular study aspects and be comfortable with the fact that I may or may not be right, and that I more than likely will come to indefinite conclusions.
Friday, February 24, 2012
Moyga, Ntoro, and Family Values
Wednesday, February 22, 2012
Cadbury and Cocoa
Tuesday, February 21, 2012
Overcoming my Ophelia
- Everyday was a powerpoint lecture - the dull tool of *limited* inspiration that offers 2-D text, a few pictures, and more text. And a lot of note-taking. And often not too much class participation.
- The required texts were informative, but the reading selections were at times repetitive, or not explained or given preface when they contained challenging material.
- When students posed ideas they were often tersely "corrected," with no room for exploration. The professor basically employed just a Polonius-like show of authority
- Everyday of class is held as a fish-bowl discussion. Students face each other in a circle, and Buonforte was part of that circle
- Everyone's answers were considered. Right/wrong conclusions were explored as a class
- Readings were accompanied by journal entries that were not read by the teacher - these allowed us to record our own unexamined thought processes while reading
- The reading selection varied between the expected theorists, and maybe more risky/fringe theorists, to give us a wider understanding of what ideologies were out there, instead of just the most commonly accepted ones
Thus, I can definitely relate to the Ophelia Syndrome in a school situation. It may have been more straightforward exactly what would get me an "A" in the former class situation I described, but I barely remember anything I learned from that class. The latter situation described left me with lasting impressions, and altered the way I go about my life. It encouraged individuation, instead of just another mindless sheep following the "greats" in academia.
Friday, February 17, 2012
Questioning my Question
Wednesday, February 15, 2012
Mishaps in Methodology, and What I've Learned
#6:To -----, the social system was simple – the two extremes of rich and poor, and then the average middle, not several layers in between. Its seems that it is important to the wealthy to appear wealthy and show their wealth. They do this by sending their kids to well-known and pricey schools, and by giving money to the less fortunate.
#7:----- painted a picture very different from America. Americans are stereotypically capitalistic – each for their own. Their own hard work will benefit them and them alone. However, ----- states that Ghanaians have a more communal outlook. She could go to her neighbors for food when she was lacking, and would be treated as a family member.
#8:For rural children to gain a university education, they would have to migrate to the urban areas. This could be a problem if they want to stay near family to help. Having no universities in nearby villages presents a problem.
Monday, February 13, 2012
Tribal Customs of the Primitive Peoples in America
Friday, February 10, 2012
Place
Besides our cultural ties to place, Edward Casey acknowledges that even the abstract boundaries of place are essential to our reality when he states, “the limit of an existing thing is intrinsic to its being, a condition for its very existence” (Getting Back into Place 15). Without the boundaries of place, even the emplacement we feel within our bodies, we would be everywhere. If we were everywhere we would also be nowhere, because there would be no 'where.'"
The concepts we learned about place and how it is affected by culture were highly fascinating. Our place limits the way we even use our bodies. Walls and hallways are boundaries that determine the movements we make and the pathways we follow. This can be very different from culture to culture. For example, when we watched that video clip of Ghanaians eating, they were in a very cramped space. From my perspective as a middle class American, I would never imagine an eating space that small. Also, place can be defined very differently cross-culturally. In many places in the United States, the dinner table is a very social place, where people can converse and catch up. However, we learned that in Ghana it can be considered rude to approach someone while they are eating; therefore, maybe the dinner table is not defined as a socially interactive place.
It is interesting to see how much certain aspects can define a culture. Before my anthropology classes, I was not aware at all how much time, place, language, animate and inanimate objects all have major roles in shaping us as human beings, and determining our lifestyles. It will be intriguing to pay closer attention to these aspects as I compare my native culture with Ghanaian culture.
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Learning Twi
Monday, February 6, 2012
Anthropology and Zion
- The more I learn, the more I realize how much I do not know. When I was younger I figured the more I found out, the smarter I would be. Now I realize the more I expand my knowledge, the more I realize how inadequate my knowledge span truly is.
- I have learned new definitions of what it means to be a child of God. Learning about culture and the society of man really shifts one's views or erases preconceptions one may not have ever known they had.
- I have found more evidence that there is a God. For one thing, because I do not think pure science, outside of the context of religion and creation, could create such complex unknowable beings and societies. Evolution alone could not be responsible for this. Also, God gives me hope that the worldwide and timeless suffering taken on by humans will someday be universally lifted through the Atonement.